Let's Chart About That!

Theme Light Dark

Episode

Tillamook includes 34 scored items from the "Gut Check" series from Good Mythical Morning.

In all charts, Rhett's data is RED, Link's data is BLUE, and combined data is PURPLE.

Episode Tillamook

Items scored 34

Ranking method Raw Score

Abstract

This episode report summarizes published Gut Check scores for N = 34 items in Tillamook, including rankings, score distributions, disagreement counts, and derived measures.

Dataset snapshot refreshed June 3, 2026 6:57 AM.

Methods

The selected ranking method is applied within this episode only. Rank ties are preserved. Original final rankings are reported separately from recalculated rankings shown under the selected method.

Raw score. Sum of Rhett and Link scores.

Formal notation R = S_R + S_L

Normalized score. Episode-relative placement measure.

Formal notation N = f_episode(R)

Consensus score. Normalized score with disagreement penalty.

Formal notation C = g_episode(N, |S_R - S_L|)

Results

1. Combined Results Raw Score

Table 1. Original Episode Final Ranking
Final Rank	Item	Total Score	Rhett	Link	Numeric Rank
1	Peaches & Cream	168	84	84	1
2	Oregon Strawberry	161	77	84	6
3	Chocolate Peanut Butter	166	78	88	3
4	Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	166	82	84	2

Table 2. Rank Drift from Original Final Ranking Raw Score
Item	Final Rank	Method Rank	Drift	Total Score	Rhett	Link
Oregon Strawberry	2	6	4	161	77	84
Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	4	2	2	166	82	84
Peaches & Cream	1	1	0	168	84	84
Chocolate Peanut Butter	3	3	0	166	78	88

Figure 1. Distribution of Rhett and Link scores within Tillamook.

Figure 2. Distribution of combined total scores within Tillamook.

Figure 3. Score distribution by ranking method after rescaling each method to a 0-100 index.

Figure 4. Rhett-Link agreement within Tillamook.

Figure 5. Score range by score source within Tillamook on a 0-100 scale.

Figure 6. Items with the largest absolute Rhett-Link score difference.

Score source	10	20	30	40	50	60	70	80	100
Rhett	1	0	0	1	4	6	13	8	1
Link	2	3	3	5	3	6	6	6	0
Combined	1	0	1	5	7	6	8	6	0

Figure 7. Heatmap of score bucket counts by score source.

Average Score

125

Peanut Butter Quotient*

42

The average score for a peanut butter item is 166. The average score for a non-peanut butter item is 124.

Nice! Factor**

0

Recipients: None

Figure 8. Peanut Butter Quotient by score source.

Figure 9. Nice! Factor occurrences by score source.

Table 3. Highest-Ranked Items Raw Score
Rank	Item	Total Score	Rhett	Link
1	Peaches & Cream	168	84	84
2	Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	166	82	84
	Chocolate Peanut Butter	166	78	88
3	White Chocolate Raspberry	164	79	85
4	Banana Split	161	83	78
	Oregon Strawberry	161	77	84
5	Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough	155	73	82
6	Chocolate	151	80	71
	Mudslide	151	81	70
7	Custard Cold Brew Chocolate Chip	150	80	70
8	Cookies & Cream	146	67	79
9	Udderly Chocolate	145	77	68
	Custard Bing Cherry Cheesecake	145	85	60
10	Custard Maple & Candied Pecan	142	72	70

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Table 4. Lowest-Ranked Items Raw Score
Rank	Item	Total Score	Rhett	Link
1	Oregon Hazlenut & Salted Caramel	35	15	20
2	French Vanilla	75	55	20
3	Custard Salted Caramel	87	50	37
4	Mountain Huckleberry	88	40	48
5	Oregon Dark Cherry	94	74	20
	Malted Moo Shake	94	62	32
6	Butter Pecan	96	84	12
7	Caramel Toffee Crunch	100	70	30
8	Coffee Almond Fudge	103	61	42
9	Marionberry Pie	110	50	60
10	Custard Oregon Strawberry Shortcake	111	57	54

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Table 5. Largest Score Differences
Rank	Item	Score Difference	Rhett	Link
1	Mint Chocolate Chip	88	100	12
2	Butter Pecan	72	84	12
3	Oregon Dark Cherry	54	74	20
4	Caramel Toffee Crunch	40	70	30
5	Monster Coookie	35	75	40
6	French Vanilla	35	55	20
7	Malted Moo Shake	30	62	32
8	Birthday Cake	26	71	45
9	Custard Bing Cherry Cheesecake	25	85	60
10	Chocolate Chip	25	74	49

Table 6. Full Combined Ranking Raw Score
Rank	Item	Total Score	Rhett	Link
1	Peaches & Cream	168	84	84
2	Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	166	82	84
	Chocolate Peanut Butter	166	78	88
3	White Chocolate Raspberry	164	79	85
4	Banana Split	161	83	78
	Oregon Strawberry	161	77	84
5	Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough	155	73	82
6	Chocolate	151	80	71
	Mudslide	151	81	70
7	Custard Cold Brew Chocolate Chip	150	80	70
8	Cookies & Cream	146	67	79
9	Udderly Chocolate	145	77	68
	Custard Bing Cherry Cheesecake	145	85	60
10	Custard Maple & Candied Pecan	142	72	70
11	Vanilla Bean	136	71	65
12	Old Fashioned Vanilla	128	68	60
13	Waffle Cone Swirl	127	60	67
14	Chocolate Chip	123	74	49
15	Caramel Swirl	122	67	55
16	Rocky Road	120	70	50
17	Birthday Cake	116	71	45
18	Monster Coookie	115	75	40
19	Mint Chocolate Chip	112	100	12
20	Custard Oregon Strawberry Shortcake	111	57	54
21	Marionberry Pie	110	50	60
22	Coffee Almond Fudge	103	61	42
23	Caramel Toffee Crunch	100	70	30
24	Butter Pecan	96	84	12
25	Malted Moo Shake	94	62	32
	Oregon Dark Cherry	94	74	20
26	Mountain Huckleberry	88	40	48
27	Custard Salted Caramel	87	50	37
28	French Vanilla	75	55	20
29	Oregon Hazlenut & Salted Caramel	35	15	20

Figure 10. Counts of instances in which Rhett, Link, or neither assigned the higher score.

Table 7. Higher Score Counts
Episode	Rhett	Link	Tie
Tillamook	23	10	1

Results

2. Rhett

Figure 11. Distribution of Rhett scores within Tillamook.

Average Score

70

Peanut Butter Quotient*

8

Rhett's average score for a peanut butter item is 78. Rhett's average score for a non-peanut butter item is 70.

Nice! Factor**

0

Recipients: None

Table 8. Rhett Highest-Ranked Items
Rank	Item	Score
1	Mint Chocolate Chip	100
2	Custard Bing Cherry Cheesecake	85
3	Peaches & Cream	84
	Butter Pecan	84
4	Banana Split	83
5	Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	82
6	Mudslide	81
7	Chocolate	80
	Custard Cold Brew Chocolate Chip	80
8	White Chocolate Raspberry	79
9	Chocolate Peanut Butter	78
10	Oregon Strawberry	77
	Udderly Chocolate	77

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Table 9. Rhett Lowest-Ranked Items
Rank	Item	Score
1	Oregon Hazlenut & Salted Caramel	15
2	Mountain Huckleberry	40
3	Custard Salted Caramel	50
	Marionberry Pie	50
4	French Vanilla	55
5	Custard Oregon Strawberry Shortcake	57
6	Waffle Cone Swirl	60
7	Coffee Almond Fudge	61
8	Malted Moo Shake	62
9	Caramel Swirl	67
	Cookies & Cream	67
10	Old Fashioned Vanilla	68

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Results

3. Link

Figure 12. Distribution of Link scores within Tillamook.

Average Score

56

Peanut Butter Quotient*

33

Link's average score for a peanut butter item is 88. Link's average score for a non-peanut butter item is 55.

Nice! Factor**

0

Recipients: None

Table 10. Link Highest-Ranked Items
Rank	Item	Score
1	Chocolate Peanut Butter	88
2	White Chocolate Raspberry	85
3	Peaches & Cream	84
	Custard Sea Salt & Honeycomb Toffee	84
	Oregon Strawberry	84
4	Chocolate Chip Cookie Dough	82
5	Cookies & Cream	79
6	Banana Split	78
7	Chocolate	71
8	Mudslide	70
	Custard Cold Brew Chocolate Chip	70
	Custard Maple & Candied Pecan	70
9	Udderly Chocolate	68
10	Waffle Cone Swirl	67

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Table 11. Link Lowest-Ranked Items
Rank	Item	Score
1	Butter Pecan	12
	Mint Chocolate Chip	12
2	Oregon Hazlenut & Salted Caramel	20
	French Vanilla	20
	Oregon Dark Cherry	20
3	Caramel Toffee Crunch	30
4	Malted Moo Shake	32
5	Custard Salted Caramel	37
6	Monster Coookie	40
7	Coffee Almond Fudge	42
8	Birthday Cake	45
9	Mountain Huckleberry	48
10	Chocolate Chip	49

Note. Tied scores share rank labels; tables include all items in the first ten rank groups.

Notes

4. Definitions and Notes

* Peanut Butter Quotient is calculated as the difference between the average score for peanut-butter-focused flavors and the average score for non-peanut-butter flavors. Flavors designated as peanut-butter-focused in this episode are: Chocolate Peanut Butter

Formal notation PBQ = x̄_PB - x̄_non-PB

** Nice! Factor is the number of times a score of 69 appears.

Formal notation NF = Σ 1(score = 69)

Rank Drift is the absolute difference between the original final rank and the rank produced by the currently selected ranking method.

Limitations. Scores are treated as interval values although the underlying tasting process is subjective.